The NFL draft is over, which means it’s time for the yearly round of “did they really just do that?” Right on schedule, the internet is full of hot takes on the baffling choices made by otherwise smart football people. The general mood falls somewhere between a laugh and a confused “only in the NFL.”
Before you write it off as the NFL being the NFL, though, consider this. The same mess of incentives and biases behind those strange draft trades and picks is alive and well in your company. The draft just puts it all under bright TV lights with a ticking clock. That makes it a great, high-stakes lab for watching how organizations behave and how often people ignore the economics.
If you’ve never followed it, the NFL draft is where the 32 teams split up the best college players each spring. The idea is simple. The worst team picks first, the second-worst picks second, and so on. In theory, this helps bad teams get better and keeps the league competitive. But teams can also trade their draft slots, kind of like kids swapping Pokémon cards. A team at pick five might trade with a team at pick ten and grab an extra pick or two later in the draft, or in next year’s draft, to make the deal worth it.
Here’s where it gets interesting. Back in 2005, Nobel Prize-winning economist Richard Thaler and fellow economist Cade Massey published a study that shook things up. They showed teams would do better by trading down for more picks instead of chasing the top slots. Those early picks aren’t the sure path to long-term success people think they are. Stocking up on more chances later in the draft is statistically the smarter play.
If I know about this study, trust me, every NFL team knows about it in far more detail than I do. Thaler and Massey have even sat in NFL war rooms and shared their draft advice. Many teams have their own analytics staff and still hire outside experts. And yet, every year, teams trade up anyway and make choices that ignore the hard numbers.
So why do they keep doing it? Spoiler alert: football doesn’t own this problem. The causes will sound familiar to anyone who’s ever worked on a team trying to get something done, whether that’s launching a big product or just getting everyone aligned on the quarterly report.
It all starts with incentives. The official line in the draft room is “let’s make this team better!” Dig a little deeper, though, and everyone’s idea of how to get there starts to get pretty squishy.
Fear plays a big role. Take the General Manager, the person in charge of the roster and draft day decisions. In theory, the GM cares about long-term team success. In reality, most GMs have two or three seasons to show results before they’re out of a job. That pushes them toward flashy players who can help right away, even when a slower-developing player might be worth more down the road. What good are two extra picks next year to a GM who won’t be around next year? It’s the business version of grabbing the low-hanging fruit because you’re afraid the ladder will collapse.
Fear drives a lot of decisions in any organization. Performance expectations come with every job. When the fear of failing or missing short-term goals takes over, though, you get one choice after another that trades long-term gains for short-term self-protection. The best teams and companies usually have leaders who can manage that tension. They build an environment where people feel safe enough to take care of today’s needs and still chase a bigger long-term vision.
Then you have the clash of expertise. The GM isn’t alone in the draft room. There’s the head coach, a bunch of assistant coaches (each with offensive, defensive, or position-specific favorites), and the scouts whose job is to find and evaluate talent. Each of them brings biases built over years in their corner of the game. Of course the defensive coordinator is drooling over that shutdown cornerback, even if it costs the team future picks.
This looks exactly like life inside a company. Engineering, sales, marketing, and product all have strong opinions about the “right” way to solve a problem, shaped by what they know best. That’s fine. It’s why they were hired. The trick is for leadership to pull all those viewpoints together and point them at what’s best for the whole organization instead of one department.
And don’t forget plain old personal motives. You think everyone in that room only cares about the team winning? Bless your heart. Go back to our defensive coordinator, still dreaming about that game-changing defensive star. A great defense helps the team, sure. It also makes him look like a genius. Even if the offense is a mess, a dominant defense can earn him praise and maybe a head coaching job when the current coach gets fired for, well, running a mediocre offense. These personal goals are always hiding in the background of big decisions, and nobody likes to talk about them.
That’s product work in a nutshell. Like it or not, everyone on a team has their own mix of personal and professional goals, and they don’t always line up. Maybe the design team wants something gorgeous for their portfolio while the engineers worry about technical debt. Maybe the sales team quietly made promises to clients that are about to crash into the product roadmap. I once worked on a project where some team members had bonuses tied to a metric that actually worked against the project’s main goal. A good leader has to be part psychologist and part detective, figuring out these hidden agendas and steering everyone back toward the shared goal.
So it’s easy for us armchair quarterbacks (pun intended) to laugh at draft day drama and call it a football thing. Look a little closer, though, and it’s a familiar picture. The same tangle of incentives, biases, and personal ambition behind those head-scratching picks is bubbling under the surface of countless projects at work.
No NFL team nails every pick on draft day, and no company makes perfect decisions either. Some risks will look foolish in hindsight, and some choices just won’t work out. The NFL teams that win year after year have something in common with the companies that do. Their leaders know how to handle all those competing interests and make calls that pay off now and keep paying off later. That’s how you end up with a lot more wins than losses.